Joshua Goldman
Joshua Goldman
min read · June 16, 2025 · Entertainment

Unveiling Twin Peaks' Real Mystery: The Haunting Truth Behind Hazel Drew

Thirty-five years after she first captivated a television audience, Laura Palmer - the tragic beauty at the center of the Twin Peaks mystery - continues to haunt us

The Mysterious Case of Hazel Drew: Uncovering the Dark Secrets Behind a 1908 Murder

Thirty-five years after her tragic fate captivated audiences, Laura Palmer's eerie presence still haunts us. But what if I told you that there was another real-life beauty, shrouded in mystery and controversy, who inspired the iconic character? Enter Hazel Drew, a 19-year-old governess whose untimely demise in 1908 has remained an enigma for over a century. Her story has now been reignited by amateur sleuth Jerry C. Drake's new book, Hazel Was a Good Girl: Solving the Murder that Inspired Twin Peaks, which sheds light on the dark secrets surrounding her murder.

Drake's journey into the depths of Hazel's case began with a series of inexplicable events. He started experiencing vivid dreams and visions, which he initially dismissed as mere hallucinations or the product of his overactive imagination. However, these nocturnal visitations seemed to be more than just coincidences – they were messages from beyond the grave.

Hazel was just 19 when she was found dead

The Haunting of Hazel Drew

Drake's first encounter with Hazel took place in 2019, when a friend who had recently moved to Troy, near Sand Lake, New York, shared a dream about a mysterious woman appearing in their home. The woman presented a book with an unusual title: The Absence of Memory. As fate would have it, Drake's friend began experiencing similar dreams, which led them both on an unsettling journey into the world of Hazel Drew.

Their quest for answers started at Hazel's gravesite, where Drake claims to have had a heart attack-like experience. While stumbling around the cemetery, he collapsed onto a tombstone bearing the name "HAZEL." The mysterious feeling that washed over him seemed inexplicable – it was as if something otherworldly had entered his body, taking control of his actions.

Mark Frost first came up with the idea of the beautiful girl next door who leads a 'desperate double life' and ends up brutally murdered (Pictured: actress Sheryl Lee as the deceased Laura Palmer in Twin Peaks)

"I've never felt such an intense presence before," Drake recalls. "It wasn't like I was possessed or anything, but...I don't know how else to describe it."

This supernatural encounter only heightened the stakes for both Drake and his friend. As they continued their investigation, they began experiencing more inexplicable events – including a shared vision of Hazel's murder.

The Unraveling of a Century-Old Mystery

Grace Zabriskie as Sarah Palmer, Sheryl Lee as Laura Palmer and Ray Wise as Leland Palmer in the Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me movie

As Drake delved deeper into the case files, he became convinced that a cover-up had occurred in 1908. The original investigation was botched from the start, and powerful individuals at the time took advantage of the chaos to conceal the truth. Hazel's death was initially shrouded in scandal, with rumors abounding about her personal life.

However, Drake refused to accept these baseless accusations as fact. He pored over local newspaper archives, photographs, and eyewitness accounts, searching for inconsistencies that would reveal the truth.

One theory that stuck out like a sore thumb was the account of James Winters, a wealthy businessman whose testimony seemed too convenient. Was he hiding something?

The cult show features a wildly eccentric cast of inhabitants of a fictional town

"We know who kills people," Drake emphasizes. "We know how to identify prime suspects. And I believe that the data points to one person – someone who was never properly questioned or scrutinized."

The photograph of this suspect, taken in 1908, remains a pivotal piece of evidence. Drake believes it's more than just circumstantial – it's proof.

Naming the Killer

Twin Peaks gained a new generation of dedicated fans following the death of filmmaker David Lynch (pictured left with his co-creator, Mark Frost, right)

In Hazel Was a Good Girl, Drake reveals his theory about the killer's identity, pointing to James Winters as the prime suspect. This revelation may shake the very foundations of the case files.

"He lied on at least two occasions," Drake says. "He was the first person questioned, and yet he never gave a reward or made a statement. It raises more questions than answers."

While this book has been written to solve the murder that inspired Twin Peaks, it's essential to remember that Hazel Drew is an enigma in her own right – not just a cautionary tale about the darker side of human nature.

The New York Times headline story on July 17, 1908

In conclusion, the case of Hazel Drew serves as a haunting reminder that some secrets are better left unspoken. But with Jerry C. Drake's persistence and research, we're getting closer to unraveling the mystery that has haunted this small town for over a century.

Hazel Was a Good Girl: Solving the Murder that Inspired Twin Peaks is now available from Clash Books. Whether you're intrigued by the supernatural, fascinated by true crime stories, or simply want to understand the eerie similarities between Hazel Drew's case and Laura Palmer's tragic fate – this book promises to captivate readers with its unique blend of mystery, suspense, and historical intrigue.

[1] The image in this article is not available.

Visiting his friend in the winter of 2020, they sought out Hazel’s grave in the local cemetery

He claims that once he put his hands on Hazel's grave, his symptoms disappeared

In October 2024, the Sand Lake Historical Society put up a historical marker to commemorate Hazel's death and her continued presence in the area

Investigator Dale Cooper, played by Kyle MacLachlan in the show (pictured right), claims he has finally solved the case

Drake's investigations created what he calls his 'crazy wall' of evidence and clues

‘I went down to Manory's - it felt just like the real version of the diner from Twin Peaks... That was the day I found the first photograph of the man I think was her killer'

'That guy in the picture was the guy we saw in the cemetery who said,