Joshua Goldman
Joshua Goldman
min read · August 24, 2025 · Entertainment

The Royal Rift: Early Signs of Tension Between the 'Fab Four'

All eyes were on Princes William and Harry as they strode out with their partners Kate Middleton and Meghan Markle for their first ever joint event on February 28, 2018

The Fab Four's Fiery Fate: A Tale of Royal Rivalry and Warring Wives

It was supposed to be a glorious celebration, a triumphant debut for the "Fab Four" - William and Kate, Harry and Meghan - as they launched their joint charitable venture, the Royal Foundation. But beneath the surface, the cracks were already beginning to show.

As the cameras rolled on that fateful day, the tension between the brothers-in-law was palpable. Judi James, a renowned body language expert, observed: "The expectation was that we had a new friend and 'sister' for Kate in much the same way that Fergie and Diana paired off, plus a very glamorous royal quartet to team up for their campaigns and charities." But what we got was something entirely different.

The Royal Foundation Forum served as the informal royal 'working debut' of Harry's then-fiancée, American actress Meghan, and the all-smiling team sat down for what would be a 22-minute joint interview

Meghan Markle, fresh from her whirlwind romance with Harry, was the real star of the show. With her trademark confidence and charm, she took center stage, effortlessly stealing the spotlight. In a move that would prove to be both her greatest asset and most significant misstep, Meghan boldly encouraged women to "use their voices" rather than "find" them, praising women for speaking out against sexual harassment in the wake of the Harvey Weinstein scandal.

But this was not just a noble cause - it was also a fundamental breach of royal protocol. As Tom Bower noted in his 2022 book, Revenge: "Meghan's speech was based on her 'virtuous thoughts' and she caused Kate to react with a 'frozen expression'." The implications were clear: Meghan had veered into the most sensitive of areas, sparking a fierce debate about the limits of royal influence.

As the interview progressed, the body language expert observed subtle signs of tension between the wives. "Meghan's energy and confidence might not have been a surprise, given her career and campaign experience before meeting Harry," James noted, "but Kate was heavily pregnant and looked and sounded tired here, sitting back in her seat while speaking softly and smiling politely."

Body language expert Judi James told the Daily Mail: 'There was a soft-focus filter over this

Meanwhile, Meghan seemed to be exerting her influence over the conversation, using her trademark charm to steer the discussion towards her own causes. But it wasn't just Meghan's words that were causing controversy - her actions spoke louder than any statement. "Meghan clearly knew how to work and hold a room actively while Kate, as a royal, had only ever needed to adopt a more passive approach," James observed.

As the event drew to a close, the question of disagreements between the Fab Four was raised. William tried to laugh off the sensitive topic with a drawn-out "Ohhhh yes", but Harry jumped in quickly to clarify that they were simply engaging in "healthy disagreements". But Judi James had other ideas: "It's when the group are asked about disagreements that they all chuckle knowingly," she noted, "but when you look closely, you can see Meghan dropping her head and hiding behind her hair - it's a classic sign of discomfort."

Meghan's responses seemed natural enough, but to those who knew her, there was something more at play. "She raises one hand to her face to whisper playfully when out at events with Kate," James observed, "but when royals are on display, there's a tendency to keep emotions and inner thoughts suppressed or hidden by the use of regal smiles or even a poker face."

Royal author Tom Bower wrote that Meghan's speech was based on her 'virtuous thoughts' and he claimed it caused Kate to react with a 'frozen expression'

And then there was Harry - visibly seething beneath his surface. He sat grim-faced beside Meghan as she spoke about her campaigns, glancing down or rocking from side to side in his chair. His eyes betrayed a deep-seated frustration that would soon come to a head.

As the interview drew to a close, the question of their last argument was raised. Harry tried to deflect it with a joke, but William jumped in quickly to quip: "Is it resolved? We don't know!" Meghan chimed in at the end with her trademark wit: "Togetherness at its finest."

But as we now know, this was not just a lighthearted remark. Behind the scenes, tensions between the Fab Four were reaching boiling point. Less than two years later, the Royal Foundation would be dissolved and Meghan and Harry would announce their decision to leave the UK and set up their own charity.

As well as grabbing the headlines with her provocative speech, Meghan's talk also caused traditional royalists to raise an eyebrow

In retrospect, it's clear that this moment marked the beginning of the end for the Fab Four. As Tina Brown noted in her bestselling 2022 royal book The Palace Papers: "Meghan's brazen speech didn't sit well with her future sister-in-law," Kate. "Few knew that it was she who had been the prime mover of the foundation's mental health campaign, crafted after careful consultation with mental health professionals, policy experts, and Palace advisers."

It was an awkward dynamic - one that would prove to be impossible to sustain. And so, as we look back on this pivotal moment in royal history, it's clear that the "Fab Four" were not destined for greatness. Instead, their fiery fate would seal their place in the annals of royal rivalry and warring wives.

In a shocking turn of events, a year after the launch, the Sussexes announced they would be leaving the Royal Foundation to set up their own charity. The move was seen as a major blow to the "Fab Four" experiment, with many commentators predicting that it marked the beginning of the end for this ambitious venture.

Royal biographer Tom Bower wrote about Meghan's speech at the Royal Foundation event in his 2022 book, Revenge

As Christine Ross and Christina Garibaldi noted on their podcast Royally Us: "At the time, we didn't think anything of it, but when you go back and watch the clips from the event, it's noticeable." The cracks were already showing - a fissure that would soon spread, ultimately tearing apart this once-promising partnership.

In conclusion, the Royal Foundation Launch was not just an exciting new development in royal philanthropy - it was also a cautionary tale of the dangers of mixing politics and palace protocol. As we reflect on this pivotal moment in history, one thing is clear: the "Fab Four" were always destined for disaster.

Judi James said: 'As Kate speaks here, Meghan turns her head to offer some active listening signals: face-watching, micro-nodding and performing a gentle curling mouth smile to suggest encouragement'

'When Kate talks about them all coming together, Meghan looks down in a gesture that suggests a pensive moment,' wrote the body language expert

Harry, Meghan, Kate and William are pictured during the first Royal Foundation Forum

Beneath the surface, the cracks in the relationship between the brothers and their partners were beginning to appear

Many commentators see the Royal Foundation Launch as the beginning of the end of the 'Fab Four'

Royal author Tina Brown is pictured in 2022