Joshua Goldman
Joshua Goldman
min read · June 22, 2025 · Entertainment

Primate Pranks and Peacock Parties: Mamie Fish's Gilded Age Extravaganzas

Mamie - played by the actor Ashlie Atkinson in HBO ’s The Gilded Age - benefited from that rare thing in the late-19th century: a marriage of love

Get ready to indulge in a scandalous saga of glitz, glamour, and utter chaos - the story of Mamie Fish, the life and soul of New York's Gilded Age party scene.

Behind that scowling face in the countless photographs lies a woman who was anything but dull. With a wit as sharp as her humor, Mamie could charm even the most skeptical of souls. And it's no wonder - she was married to Stuyvesant Fish, a childhood friend born with a silver spoon so big it was practically a soup ladle.

The Fishes' marriage was a match made in heaven, or rather, a match made in the midst of Manhattan's high society. Mamie was a true original, and her husband adored her for her eccentricities - including her infamous "duck pond dinner" party, where the pièce de résistance was a live duck frolicking on the dining table.

Actress Carrie Coon is seen above in HVO's gilded age

But not everyone was enamored with Mamie's unorthodox style. The likes of Ward McAllister, that stalwart of propriety and compiler of the esteemed list of "the 400," deemed her parties too wild, too loud, and altogether too... Mamie. He famously "read her out of society," warning other hostesses to steer clear of this "hopeless vulgarian."

Undeterred by the snub, Mamie plunged headfirst into the fray, determined to throw the wildest, most unforgettable parties America had ever seen. And boy, did she deliver! Her notorious Dog's Dinner party featured canine guests dressed in their finest attire, complete with diamond collars - and one pup so well-fed he passed out on his plate.

But that was just the beginning. Mamie went on to host a string of legendary bashes, each more outrageous than the last. There was the Mardi Gras Ball, where guests wore devil-red attire and sipped champagne while surrounded by a "Satanic Flower Garden" - complete with fire-like blooms and pitchfork party favors.

Her initial soirees displeased societal arbiters like Ward McAllister, the man played by Nathan Lane in the HBO series (right)

Then there was the Reversible Dance, where everyone wore their clothes back to front (because, why not?). And who could forget her Harvest Ball, featuring scarecrows, haybales, and thousands of sunflowers, all set amidst a rustic farmhouse backdrop?

But perhaps Mamie's crowning achievement was her Valentine's ball, where children dressed as Cupid delivered love notes between guests - or, if they got bored, watched a troupe of ballerinas twirling with tiny electric lights illuminating their skirts.

And let's not forget the infamous Prince Del Drago party, where the "eligible prince" turned out to be none other than a monkey in a miniature dinner jacket. The little scamp even managed to swing from the chandelier and fling lightbulbs at guests - a feat that left everyone in attendance simultaneously shocked and delighted.

Season 3 of HBO’s The Gilded Age starts on June 22

Through it all, Mamie remained the consummate hostess - always one step ahead of the curve, always pushing the boundaries of what was considered acceptable in high society. And when she finally passed away in 1939, her legacy lived on, inspiring generations to come.

So, the next time you find yourself at a themed party, remember Mamie Fish - the trailblazing maven who brought elegance, humor, and sheer pandemonium to America's party culture. And don't forget to give credit where credit is due: to The Scholarly Note (thescholarlynote.com) for keeping her remarkable story alive.

Glitz, Glam, and a Damn Good Time by Jennifer Wright is published by Grand Central Publishing on August 5, a testament to Mamie's enduring impact on the world of parties.

Mamie was known to be very funny – despite what the many photographs showing her scowling grimly into the camera may suggest

Before long, she had bought a house in Newport, where she resolved to throw the wildest, most unique parties America had ever seen

Mamie’s invitations were the hottest tickets in town (Mamie is pictured far right)

Jennifer Wright

Mamie complained that the long operas society loved attending ‘surpassed everything I ever knew in the line of boredom’

Mamie's Rhode Island home was the venue for some of her wildest parties

Only when they got there did they discover their eligible prince was actually a monkey. He wore a tiny dinner jacket. (Pictured: A file photo of a monkey dressed for dinner)