Joshua Goldman
Joshua Goldman
min read · October 13, 2025 · Entertainment

Paul Mescal Shines in Oscar-Worthy 'Hamnet': A Sublime Shakespearean Drama

Paul Mescal's new movie Hamnet has been praised as 'sublime' and Oscar-worthy as critics lauded his portrayal of Shakespeare in a sea of hugely-positive reviews

SHAKESPEAREAN SENSATION: Paul Mescal's New Movie Hamnet Steals the Show with Rave Reviews and Oscar Buzz

In a dramatic turn of events, Irish heartthrob Paul Mescal is making waves in Hollywood with his latest film, Hamnet, which has critics swooning over its "sublime" adaptation of Maggie O'Farrell's award-winning novel. The 29-year-old actor takes on the iconic role of William Shakespeare in this historical drama, opposite Jessie Buckley as his on-screen wife Agnes.

As the cast list reads like a who's who of Hollywood A-listers, including Taylor Swift's ex Joe Alwyn and Oscar nominee Emily Watson, expectations were high. But no one could have predicted just how stunningly good Hamnet would turn out to be. The movie follows the star-crossed couple as they grapple with the devastating loss of their 11-year-old son, Hamnet, to the plague.

The Irish actor, 29, plays William Shakespeare in the historical drama alongside actress Jessie Buckley , 35, who takes on the role of his on-screen wife Agnes (seen)

TheScholarlyNote.com's film critic Brian Viner was over the moon with his perfect five-star review, gushing: "Deeply soulful, altogether intoxicating tearjerker... Look out for those Oscar nominations!" He lavished praise on Paul Mescal, declaring that his performance is "career-best stuff" and a testament to his growing talent. Not one to hold back, Viner also raved about Jessie Buckley's tour-de-force turn as Agnes, saying she unleashes "visceral emotion without over-acting."

But he wasn't the only critic to fall head over heels for Hamnet. The Telegraph chimed in with their own glowing five-star review, cooing: "Mescal has simply never been better... Buckley doesn't so much act as seem to discover her character before your eyes." They praised the film's adaptation, saying it is "sublime" and that there's still a sense of "freshness" to the story despite being based on one of Shakespeare's most famous plays.

The Guardian also weighed in with their four-star review, praising both Paul Mescal and Jessie Buckley for their exceptional performances. Reviewer Richard Lawson was particularly impressed by Jessie's turn as Agnes, saying she "wholly envelops the film, giving staggering breath and body to Hamnet's portrait of loss." He lauded Paul Mescal as well, stating that he is "far more expressive than he's been allowed in quieter films."

Based on Maggie O'Farrell's award-winning novel, the movie follows the pair as they struggle to come to terms with the loss of their 11-year-old son, Hamnet, to the plague (seen at UK premiere)

Rolling Stone was equally effusive, calling Chloé Zhao's adaptation "rigorous, moving, and altogether transcendent" and praising Jessie Buckley for her "career-defining performance as Agnes." They also raved about Paul Mescal's role, saying it is played with "jagged sensitivity."

The Times joined the chorus of praise, awarding Hamnet a perfect five stars and declaring that it will be an "Oscar frontrunner." Reviewer Kevin Maher described the final scenes as "harrowing, meaningful, and magnificently sad," adding: "You might want to yell out, 'Make it stop!' This is, instantly, the essential Shakespeare movie."

And if all this wasn't enough, Variety also gave Hamnet a glowing review, praising Jessie Buckley for her "heroic performance" and Chloé Zhao's direction as "radical... and unwatchable." They praised Paul Mescal for bringing a new level of nuance to his role as Shakespeare.

The Daily Mail's reviewer praised leading man Paul saying his work in the project is 'career-best stuff', adding: 'Look out for those Oscar nominations!'

But amidst all the praise, there's also some juicy gossip. It seems that Paul Mescal is set to star in another classic remake - this time Oliver! - with theatre producer Sir Cameron Mackintosh at the helm. The project has been plagued by controversy in the past, but now it looks like they're finally getting it right. With huge stars including Florence Pugh and Paul Mescal lined up for key roles, fans can't wait to see what they bring to the iconic story.

Hamnet is set to hit UK cinemas on January 9, so be sure to grab your tickets and get ready to experience this Shakespearean sensation for yourself!

**P.S. Don't forget to keep an eye out for Paul Mescal's upcoming projects - we have a feeling he's going to be making some serious waves in the film industry soon!

Elsewhere The Telegraph also gave it five stars, saying the 'sublime adaptation couldn't have been done any better'

Hamnet will be released in the UK on January 9 and is based on the bestselling book