Joshua Goldman
Joshua Goldman
min read · September 10, 2025 · Entertainment

Morgan Wallen's Bat Blunder: Country Star Accidentally Hits Baseball Legend's Wife

MLB legend Jose Bautista watched as Morgan Wallen accidentally threw a bat at his wife

MORGAN WALEN'S BATTY BLUNDER: COUNTRY STAR EMBARRASSMENT ROCKS TORONTO SHOW

In a cringe-worthy moment that will leave fans of country music star Morgan Wallen speechless, the singer's attempts to emulate his baseball hero Jose Bautista went horribly awry on Friday night. The "I'm The Problem" tour stop at Toronto's Rogers Centre turned into a nightmare for the six-time MLB All-Star and his wife Neisha.

The drama unfolded when Wallen, sporting a bold swagger reminiscent of his high school days as a pitcher at Gibbs High School in Tennessee, was handed a bat by Bautista himself. The country crooner, who has been flaunting his baseball skills during his walkouts on this tour – including bringing out legends like Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens – tried to recreate the iconic "bat flip" move made famous by his friend Bautista.

Neisha, seen with Jose, initially screamed after being hit but said she was fine

However, in a stunning display of poor coordination, Wallen's swing connected with nothing but air, and he flung the bat wildly across the floor. The unsuspecting Neisha Bautista, who was recording the moment on her phone, became an unwitting participant in this disaster when the flying bat struck her squarely on the arm.

The clip, posted to Neisha's Instagram story, captures the chaos that ensued: she yelps in shock as the bat whizzes past her, drops her phone, and frantically glances around for help. "S*. You okay?" a concerned bystander asks, rushing over to comfort her.

As Neisha reassures them that she's fine, Bautista himself appears stunned, his hands covering his mouth in dismay. The usually suave baseball legend looked like he'd just witnessed a foul ball land squarely on his head.

Bautista is best known for his time with the Toronto Blue Jays, where he spent a decade

While the moment was undoubtedly mortifying for Wallen, it did provide some unexpected entertainment for concertgoers at Rogers Centre. We can only imagine what Bautista's wife must have been thinking as she quickly composed herself and returned to recording the show with her phone – maybe wondering if this infamous "bat blunder" would make its way onto social media.

Wallen, known for his smooth vocals and crowd-pleasing live performances, has had a whirlwind few months. His tour has brought out some of baseball's biggest names, and it seems he was trying to bring the excitement of the diamond into the arena. But while Bautista is no stranger to high-pressure situations on the field – remember those unforgettable Blue Jays teams that made deep playoff runs in 2016 and 2017? – this particular moment had all the makings of a major meltdown.

The six-time All-Star spent 15 years in the MLB, racking up an impressive 344 home runs across eight different franchises. His decade-long tenure with the Toronto Blue Jays has him second on their all-time list for homers hit, and he even led the league in dingers twice (2010 and 2011). But we're guessing this particular "bat flip" will be etched into his memory forever – as a reminder to keep an eye out for rogue country music stars with bats.

Morgan Wallen is set to wrap up his ''I'm the Problem' Tour this weekend in Edmonton

This unfortunate incident aside, Wallen's tour will wrap up on Friday and Saturday with shows in Edmonton. We can only hope that the rest of the concerts go off without any more high-stakes mishaps!