Joshua Goldman
Joshua Goldman
min read · September 11, 2025 · Entertainment

Midlife Musings: Why 'The Summer I Turned Pretty' Captivates Women Over 50

The Amazon series has become a streaming hit, with 25million viewers tuning into the first episode of season three in just one week. From left to right: Belly (Lola Tung), Jeremiah (Gavin Casalegno), Conrad (Christopher Briney), Taylor (Rain Spencer) and Steven (Sean Kaufman)

The Summer I Turned Pretty: Why Midlife Women Can't Get Enough of This Sizzling Teen Romance

In a shocking turn of events, I found myself caught up in a heated debate at a posh restaurant with three middle-aged women over who Belly, the heroine of Amazon Prime's hit series The Summer I Turned Pretty (TSITP), should choose between her two love interests. "Ladies," I chimed in, "it's obvious – Team Belly is where it's at!"

The three of us went on to dissect every juicy moment from the show, with my boyfriend looking on in bewilderment as we relived the drama-filled summers of Bell's life. If you're one of the few who hasn't been hooked by TSITP, let me enlighten you – this show is not just for young adults! It's a guilty pleasure that has captured the hearts of women from all walks of life, including yours truly.

Belly and Jeremiah cosying up. Like many, I am deeply invested in finding out which brother she will choose, writes Hannah Betts

As I sit here at 54, I must admit that I'm utterly invested in the fate of Belly and her love triangle with Conrad and Jeremiah. What is it about this show that has us midlife women swooning? Is it the nostalgic summer vibes, the swoon-worthy heroes, or the eternal question – which brother will Belly choose?

The answer lies in its timeless ingredients: a girl finds her beauty, becomes the object of two dashing chaps' affections, and must navigate her feelings. Sounds familiar, doesn't it? It's an "in bloom" moment we've all been waiting for – or wishing had happened to us back in the day.

As I reflect on my own life, I realize that TSITP taps into a deep-seated desire to be seen and cherished by someone who truly appreciates us. We may have grown up with the notion of being beautiful without makeup, but who wouldn't want to feel like a princess for once? This show delivers on that promise.

Love triangles – those agonizing decisions we thought would define our youth – are still enthralling, even as adults. In fact, they're more relatable than ever. Who hasn't found themselves caught between two opposing forces in love and life? TSITP gives us a safe space to revisit these moments without the heartache of real-life relationships.

The show's impact is so significant that Amazon had to intervene, asking viewers to simmer down over Team Conrad vs. Team Jeremiah. As for me, I'm still firmly Team Conrad – but only since my 40s, when I finally shed my moody crush phase and opted for happiness instead.

Older and wiser, I've come to realize that Belly's choice isn't just about her heart; it's about embracing the imperfections of life. We can learn a thing or two from Conrad's quiet strength and Jeremiah's carefree spirit. And who can resist the charm of those two brothers – especially when they both show up with heartfelt letters?

TSITP has become an escape room for midlife women, offering a nostalgic trip back to a time when problems were smaller and emotions ran deeper. It's a world where men still tell us we're beautiful without makeup, where relationships are built on sincerity and vulnerability.

So, join me in indulging in this guilty pleasure. With its perfect blend of romance, drama, and property porn (yes, that summer house is hotter than any of the male leads!), TSITP has become our go-to comfort show for these autumnal midlife days. Who knows? You might just find yourself binge-watching alongside me – sobbing into your cappuccino cup over Belly's fate.

And if you're wondering what all the fuss is about, don't worry; you have six days to catch up before the final episode drops at 8am next Wednesday. Trust me, it'll be worth the wait. This show has become our collective summer of love – a reminder that even in adulthood, we can still revel in the feels.

So, what are you waiting for? Get ready to join the ranks of Team Conrad (or Jeremiah, if you're feeling bold) and experience the ultimate midlife escape room. Your heart (and your cappuccino cup) will thank you.