Joshua Goldman
Joshua Goldman
min read · June 26, 2025 · Entertainment

Kristin Cavallari Accuses Craig Conover of Lying: Reveals Intimate Details and 'Overlap' Drama

Kristin Cavallari met up with Craig Conover for the first time in years during her podcast tour on E!'s Honestly Cavallari: The Headline Tour, where she accused him of some 'overlap' in their hookup and his relationship with Paige DeSorbo

SCANDALOUS ENCOUNTER: Kristin Cavallari Confronts Craig Conover Over Steamy Hookup and Paige DeSorbo Drama!

Reality TV royalty, Kristin Cavallari, is spilling all the tea on her sizzling romance with Summer House star, Craig Conover! In a shocking turn of events, Cavallari confronted Conover during her podcast tour stop in Boston, revealing the juicy details of their secretive tryst and its messy aftermath.

The 38-year-old Laguna Beach alumna had previously denied hooking up with Conover back in 2022, but she recently came clean about their brief romance on Andy Cohen's Watch What Happens Live earlier this month. During her candid confession, Cavallari revealed that she and Conover were "romantic for two seconds" before she caught wind of his relationship with Paige DeSorbo.

Kroll also set the record straight that he and Cavallari were never romantic, but she did ask Conover about any 'overlap' in their tryst and him dating DeSorbo, who he dated from October 2021 to December 2024

But things took a dramatic turn when Cavallari welcomed Conover and his Summer House co-star, Austen Kroll, to the stage. As they chatted about their first meeting, Cavallari bluntly asked Conover if he had lied to her about his relationship with DeSorbo, leaving the audience stunned.

Conover attempted to downplay the situation, insisting that there wasn't much "overlap" between his tryst with Cavallari and his romance with DeSorbo. However, the 36-year-old reality TV personality's evasive answers only seemed to fuel the drama.

Cavallari wouldn't let up, pressing Conover about their initial meeting and the details of their brief romance. She revealed that they had hooked up on multiple occasions, leaving little doubt about the nature of their relationship.

While they were discussing how they first met, Cavallari bluntly asked Conover, 'Did you lie to me about Paige?' which clearly stunned Conover

As the conversation continued, Cavallari dropped a bombshell, confessing that she had initially been oblivious to Conover's budding relationship with DeSorbo. But once she caught wind of it, she swiftly removed herself from the situation, putting an end to any romantic entanglements between them.

The drama didn't stop there! In a shocking confession, Cavallari admitted that her encounter with Conover was more than just a casual kiss – it was a full-blown hookup. And according to Cavallari's BFF, Justin Anderson, she and Conover had indeed engaged in some serious PDA during their get-together.

BACKSTAGE CHAOS

'What?' Conover said with a weak laugh, as Kroll said, 'Kristin!' as she added, 'I definitely think there was a little overlap.'

As the drama unfolded on stage, things only got messier backstage. In an exclusive interview with TheScholarlyNote.com, sources close to the situation revealed that Conover was left reeling after his confrontation with Cavallari.

"He was completely shell-shocked," a source revealed. "He couldn't believe Kristin had confronted him about Paige and their hookup. It was like he was caught off guard and didn't know how to react."

But it seems that Conover's drama wasn't limited to just the stage. According to insiders, his girlfriend, Natalie Buffett, was left feeling betrayed by his actions.

She added, 'I remember asking you and you were like,

"Natalie is still reeling from the whole ordeal," a source revealed. "She feels like Craig has been lying to her about his relationship with Kristin and Paige, and she's struggling to come to terms with it."

As the drama continues to unfold, one thing is clear: Kristin Cavallari has no intention of letting her reputation get tarnished by Conover's messy love life. In a candid confession, she revealed that their encounter was a "wake-up call," leaving her to re-evaluate her priorities and take control of her life.

"This whole situation has been a wake-up call for me," Cavallari admitted. "It's made me realize that I need to reel things in and prioritize my own well-being."

'I actually am an honest person, like I never lied to you about anything,' Craig admitted, adding, 'Eventually, it just got to the point Paige and I decided to date and we stopped talking.'

And as the drama continues to swirl around her, one thing is certain: Kristin Cavallari will not be silenced.

' How many times did I hook up with Craig? I think it was honestly like once or twice. It wasn't that much,' she said