Joshua Goldman
Joshua Goldman
min read · July 19, 2025 · Entertainment

Johnny Depp's Rocky Road: From Stardom to Struggle

Johnny Depp has been booked and busy since winning a defamation case against his ex-wife Amber Heard in 2022 - but critics have questioned the quality of his latest projects and whether he'll ever truly have a career 'comeback' (Pictured: The ex-couple pose together in New York in 2014)

Johnny Depp's Career: From Superstar to Has-Been?

The once-iconic Johnny Depp is struggling to regain his former glory after a slew of lackluster movies and allegations of domestic violence against ex-wife Amber Heard. The Pirates of the Caribbean star, 62, has seen his career go from blockbuster hits to box office bombs, with critics slamming his latest directorial effort, Modì: Three Days on the Wing of Madness.

Depp's problems began in 2018 when rumors of physical abuse against Heard surfaced, sparking a heated legal battle that ended in Depp being awarded $10 million in damages. But despite the victory, Depp's reputation remains tarnished, and his career has suffered as a result.

The world anticipated Johnny Depp's second coming when movie Jeanne du Barry dropped in 2023; but it fell flat, with critics branding it 'stale' (Pictured: The actor as King Louis XV of France in Jeanne Du Barry)

The latest evidence of this is Modì: Three Days on the Wing of Madness, a biographical drama about Italian artist Amedeo Modigliani that has been met with scathing reviews. Critics have slammed the film as an "abomination" and "filth," with one reviewer calling it "a curiously bland package." The film's poor reception has left many wondering if Depp can ever recover his former stardom.

According to PR expert Natalie Trice, the Johnny Depp we once knew is gone. "He had an almost supernatural cool factor, an enigmatic quality that made him seem like he existed on a different planet from the rest of us," she says. "But people have long memories, and once you've seen someone's dirty laundry aired in court for weeks, the text messages, the recordings, and the details of a toxic, abusive relationship are shared across the news and social media – you can't unsee it."

The problem is that Depp's reputation has been forever tarnished by his legal battles with Heard. "He's still incredibly wealthy, but he's no longer mythical," Trice says. "The mystique has been shattered, and his relationship with Amber Heard is as career-defining and legacy-leaving as roles like Pirates of the Caribbean."

Depp's directorial effort, Modì: Three Days on the Wing of Madness - a biographical drama based on the life of Italian artist Amedeo Modigliani and starring Al Pacino - also received scathing reviews

Depp's recent attempts at a comeback have only made things worse. His appearance in Jeanne du Barry, an independent French-language movie, was met with lukewarm reviews, with critics calling it "a stale and draughty period romance" and Depp's performance "nonexistent." The film's poor reception has left many wondering if Depp can ever regain his former glory.

But despite the setbacks, Trice believes that Depp still has a chance to revive his career. "He's proving that he can work again, but it's whether audiences can accept Johnny Depp as a flawed rather than untouchable icon," she says. "Right now, the focus should be on credibility and clarity. He doesn't need to win everyone over; he just needs to show stability."

The question is, can Depp turn things around? With his latest film receiving poor reviews and his reputation still reeling from the Amber Heard scandal, it's unclear if he'll ever regain his former stardom. One thing is certain, though – Johnny Depp will continue to try.

Depp was on the verge of cancellation in 2018 when rumors of him physically abusing his then-wife Amber Heard sensationally flooded airwaves (Amber Heard takes the stand during the Depp vs Heard defamation trial in Fairfax County, Virginia in 2022)

Sources: thescholarlynote.com thescholarlynote.com thescholarlynote.com

Ever since the jury ruled in favor of Depp the actor has forged a 'comeback' which has been subjected to debates and ridicule (Depp gestures to spectators in court after closing arguments at the Depp vs Heard trial in 2022)

British publicity extraordinaire Natalie Trice told FEMAIL that the Johnny Depp we once revered is long 'gone' and any attempt at salvaging his ailing career won't work (Pictured: Johnny at the height of his fame and before the legal drama in France in 1995)

When the going was good: Critics are uncertain if Johnny Depp can repeat the success of blockbusters like Pirates of the Caribbean

Amber Heard and Johnny Depp pictured in London in 2015

His upcoming movie Day Drinker could mark Depp's biggest-yet attempt to revive his silver screen career (Pictured: The actor on set of Day Drinker, set for release in 2026)

Jeanne Du Barry centers around the true life story of Jeanne Bécu, the illegitimate daughter of an impoverished seamstress born in 1743, who went on to become French king Louis XV's (played by Johnny Depp) last official mistress

Depp made a name for himself with 90s and 2000s Hollywood Blockbusters like Edward Scissorhands

The actor was once a pin-up star that dated former supermodel Kate Moss

Despite the drinking, drug use and toxicity laid bare in court, Depp remained the face of Dior Sauvage and rather than being cancelled, he is making a Hollywood comeback