Joshua Goldman
Joshua Goldman
min read · June 19, 2025 · Entertainment

Inside Vanity Fair: Nepo Drama and Staff Shock Over New Editor Appointment

Vanity Fair staff were 'blindsided' and are fiercely unhappy with Anna Wintour 's decision to appoint her daughter's nepo-baby best friend to run the magazine, a source has claimed

SCANDAL ROCKS VANITY FAIR: Anna Wintour's Nepo-Baby Choice Sparks Fury Among Staff

In a shocking move that has left Vanity Fair insiders reeling, legendary editor-in-chief Anna Wintour has appointed her daughter Bee Shaffer's best friend Mark Guiducci to run the iconic magazine. And let's just say, it's not exactly been met with open arms by the team.

Sources close to the publication have revealed that many staff members are "blindsided" and "devastated" by Wintour's decision to pass over a long list of qualified candidates in favor of her nepotistic pal. "It's like she just ignored all the other options and went with whoever was most convenient for her daughter," an insider told The Scholarly Note.

News hit the web last week that the longtime Vogue editor, 75, had picked her daughter, Bee Shaffer's close pal Mark Guiducci, 36, to run Vanity Fair following a high-profile search

Guiducci, 36, has been friends with Shaffer, 37, for years and has been spotted at high-profile parties alongside Wintour and her family. But despite his connections, many are questioning whether he's actually qualified to take the reins of a magazine like Vanity Fair.

"It's not just about the job itself," said another source. "It's about the fact that Anna is basically promoting someone who is so clearly unqualified for the role. I mean, Mark has never even been an editor-in-chief before! What makes him think he can lead one of the most iconic magazines in the world?"

Guiducci did briefly speak to staff following his appointment, but sources say it was clear he wasn't exactly bursting with excitement or vision for the magazine's future. "When he talked about Vanity Fair, everything was so vague and generic," said our insider. "It was like he didn't even know what he wanted to do with the place!"

Now, an insider has alleged that the decision has sparked immense outrage in the company, claiming that many Vanity Fair staffers feel like Guiducci (seen with Wintour) is 'not qualified'

Wintour herself has been accused of playing favorites, having jetted off to New York immediately after announcing Guiducci's appointment to attend Huma Abedin's wedding - leaving her new editor-in-chief in charge of the magazine for all intents and purposes. "It was like she just abandoned ship," said a third source. "Anna basically told everyone what they were supposed to do, then took off on vacation without even bothering to give them direction!"

But don't just take our word for it - even Wintour's own reps are denying that nepotism played a role in Guiducci's appointment. A separate insider at Vanity Fair claims that "most of the staff are actually really excited about Mark taking over and can't wait to work with him."

Of course, not everyone is buying it. Former Vanity Fair editor Graydon Carter has weighed in on the controversy, saying that he's got faith in Guiducci as a successor. "Mark has all the skills necessary for the job," he told Breaker. "He's the perfect editor for the new Vanity Fair!"

'[Staff feel] the person appointed to lead isn't qualified to do this job, he's a family friend of Anna's and her daughter,' the source said. Guiducci is seen with Shaffer in 2017

Even Tina Brown, the legendary editor-in-chief of Vogue and Harper's Bazaar, has given Guiducci her seal of approval. "Congrats to Mark Guiducci, the new editor of Vanity Fair!" she tweeted. "He's a fabulous, fresh appointment with bags of flair and fun ideas!"

But let's be real - this whole situation is looking more and more like a classic case of nepotism gone wild. And as the saying goes: "It's not what you know, it's who you know."

Guiducci's friendship with Wintour's daughter Shaffer, 37, has spanned years and the two have been photographed together frequently. He's seen with Shaffer in 2016

In 2017, he was named editor-in-chief the art publication GARAGE Magazine, owned by VICE Media. In 2020, he took on the role of creative editorial director Vogue

'People are not on board with Mark doing this job,' the insider continued, adding that when Guiducci spoke to staff following the announcement it seemed 'clear that he wasn't an experienced editor'