Fashion Fury: Fans Slam 'American Love Story' Costumes
FEUD ALERT: Sarah Pidgeon Claps Back at Haters Who Slammed Her Look on American Love Story
The drama is heating up, folks! Sarah Pidgeon, the 29-year-old actress who's about to bring Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy to life in FX's upcoming series American Love Story, has fired back at her haters with a sassy seven-word response that left us all gagging!
For those who missed it, Pidgeon will be playing the role of JFK Jr.'s wife, Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy, alongside Paul Kelly as the late senator and presidential hopeful. But the first official image from their camera tests sparked outrage among fans on Instagram, with many savage comments declaring that Pidgeon's styling was a hot mess.
"IS IT TOO LATE TO RECAST CAROLYN AND HIRE A WARDROBE DEPT THAT DRESSES HER ACCURATELY? SHE DIDN'T WEAR ILL-FITTING INEXPENSIVE CLOTHES!"
We've got to admit, the criticism was spot on. The styling of Bessette-Kennedy, who was known for her effortless chic and understated elegance, looked more like a high schooler's fashion disaster than a style icon of the 1990s. And we're not just talking about the questionable Converse shoes – which one fashion expert aptly dubbed "fashion murder"!
THE FASHION COMMUNITY UNLEASHES
Even Bessette-Kennedy's own colorist, Brad Johns, weighed in on the controversy, calling out the production for its "too 2024" take on his late client's look. He claimed that the tone of her hair was "totally wrong" and would have been a far cry from what she wore back in the day.
But it seems like Pidgeon is not having any of it! When asked about the backlash during an interview with E! News, she fired off a feisty response: "I can't wait for them to see it!"
"I feel very honored to take on this role and learn about such an incredible woman who's endured for close to 25 years now," Pidgeon added, deflecting any criticism of her character's look.
And we've got to admit, she does have a point. The controversy surrounding the styling has sparked a necessary conversation about the importance of accuracy in period dramas. As fashion expert Liz Teich pointed out, "It's not just about getting it right; it's about respecting the legacy of these iconic figures."
THE REAL CAROLYN BESSETTE-KENNEDY: A STYLE ICON OF THE 1990s
So, what made Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy a style icon of her time? For starters, she was a true original – a woman who embodied the effortless chic of the 1990s. After working as a saleswoman at Calvin Klein's boutique in Newton, Massachusetts, she landed a position dealing with high-profile clients like Annette Bening and Diane Sawyer.
Her marriage to JFK Jr. was a fairytale romance that captured the hearts of Americans everywhere – but it wasn't all glamour and glory. In fact, Bessette-Kennedy turned down interviews and offers to appear in fashion magazines because she hated being in the spotlight.
A LEGACY WORTHY OF RESPECT
As historian Marie Nicola explained to The Scholarly Note.com last week, "Ryan Murphy has built a reputation on visual precision, particularly when working with award-winning costume designers. It's surprising that he would take such liberties with Bessette-Kennedy's look."
Nicola believes that the mis-styling was intentional – a calculated move by Murphy to spark controversy and generate buzz around the show.
But let's be real, folks: at the end of the day, accuracy matters. And if you're going to portray an icon like Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy, you'd better bring your A-game!
THE PEOPLE HAVE SPOKEN
As the drama continues to unfold, we can't help but wonder what other surprises American Love Story has in store for us.
Will Pidgeon's character redeem herself with a stunning performance? Or will the controversy surrounding her look continue to overshadow the show?
One thing's for sure: this is one feud that's far from over!
