Joshua Goldman
Joshua Goldman
min read · July 3, 2025 · Entertainment

Diddy's Legal Triumph: How a Strategic Courtroom Defense Secured an Acquittal on Top Charges

Diddy was found guilty of two counts of transportation to engage in prostitution - but was found not guilty of racketeering conspiracy and two counts of sex trafficking

SEAN "DIDDY" COMBS' JAW-DROPPING ACQUITTAL: HOW THE MUSIC MOGUL'S STAR-STUDDED DEFENSE TEAM SAVED HIM FROM LIFE IN PRISON

In a shocking turn of events, Sean "Diddy" Combs, the 55-year-old music mogul, has been acquitted of sex trafficking and racketeering charges that could have landed him behind bars for life. But what's even more astonishing is how his star-studded defense team managed to save him from a harsh sentence by keeping him off the stand and presenting a simple case to the jury - while prosecutors failed miserably by focusing too much on the sleazy details, according to legal experts.

The music industry's bad boy was found guilty of only two counts of a crime - transportation to engage in prostitution - which carries a maximum sentence of 10 years in prison. However, jurors cleared him of three more serious charges, including sex trafficking and racketeering, which could have put one of hip-hop's most celebrated figures behind bars for life.

An elated Marc Agnifilo, Diddy's lead defense attorney, stands between fellow attorneys Brian Steel, Teny Geragos and Xavier Donaldson after Diddy was acquitted

But how did Diddy's defense team pull off this jaw-dropping victory? According to Alan Dershowitz, a member of OJ Simpson's infamous "dream team" of lawyers, the key was not having Diddy take the stand. "Ultimately, the smart decision was not putting OJ on the witness stand," Dershowitz told The Scholarly Note.com in an exclusive interview. "The difference is we want a complete victory. They got a partial victory, but an almost complete victory, so I commend them for excellent work."

Leading Diddy's defense team were Marc Agnifilo and Teny Geragos - the daughter of prominent lawyer Mark Geragos. And from the beginning, they presented a clear narrative that was simple to understand, reminding the jury that Diddy was "not charged with being a jerk. He's charged with running a racketeering enterprise."

Agnifilo repeatedly emphasized this point during closing arguments, telling the court: "We own the domestic violence... We own it." And it seems their strategy paid off, as prosecutors relied too heavily on the lurid details of Diddy's sex life and the infamous "freak offs" in an apparent bid to turn jurors against the star.

Experts have slammed prosecutors for focusing on the lurid details of Diddy's 'freak offs.' Lead prosecutor Christy Slavik is pictured on May 19, before the verdict

Experts say that by focusing on the shocking evidence, including videos of Diddy's alleged victims having sex with male escorts and a huge stash of baby oil and lubricant found in his homes, prosecutors only managed to make their case more distasteful. "I think there is a belief that you can make the defendant so distasteful that it’s going to lead a jury to convict on something other than the facts and evidence," former federal prosecutor Artie McConnell told The Scholarly Note.com.

"But in my experience, that rarely happens." And it seems that this time around, prosecutors were wrong. Diddy's defense team was able to credibly insist that the "freak offs" were consensual thanks to texts sent by alleged victims displaying enthusiasm for the sex events.

So what does this mean for Diddy? While he's been convicted of two counts of a crime - transportation to engage in prostitution - which carries a maximum sentence of 10 years, his defense team is already predicting that under federal sentencing guidelines, he'll likely face only about two years in prison. However, prosecutors are pushing back, citing Diddy's violence and other factors, which they say would call for at least four to five years.

Geragos is a founding partner at Agnifilo Intrater LLP and works alongside veteran criminal defense attorney Marc Agnifilo (pictured together), who has a history of representing high-profile clients

As Diddy dropped to his knees and prayed in the courtroom after the verdict, it was clear that this was a moment of pure relief - and a testament to the power of a good defense team. "Today is a victory of all victories," Agnifilo exclaimed outside Manhattan federal court at a stand of microphones.

And as Diddy left the courtroom to return to jail, he told family members including his mother and children: "I'll see you when I get out. We're going to get through this." But with a likely two-year sentence looming, it's clear that this is far from over for the music mogul. As Agnifilo promised: "We fight on and we’re going to win... And we’re not going to stop until he walks out of prison a free man to his family."

The mixed verdict capped a sordid legal odyssey that shattered Diddy's affable "Puff Daddy" image and derailed his career as a Grammy-winning artist and music executive, fashion entrepreneur, brand ambassador, and reality TV star. But for now, it seems that justice has been served - at least partially.

Dozens of bottles of baby oil and Astroglide lubricant were uncovered during the raid - as well as a box of nitrous oxide. The state focused on the huge amount of baby oil and lubricant that Diddy kept in his homes for the sex marathons

Prosecutors showed images of 'mood lighting' that Diddy allegedly used to set up the freak offs

Diddy (center) reacts after hearing his verdict in court on July 2. His attorneys are seen embracing and smiling, while he sits his head in his hands (court sketch)

Janice Combs, mother of Sean