Joshua Goldman
Joshua Goldman
min read · July 28, 2025 · Entertainment

Controversial Love: Bachelor Alum Sparks Debate on Spanking Beliefs

Bachelor #24 runner-up Madison Prewett Troutt and her husband of two years, Grant Troutt, sparked outrage after excitedly announcing they plan on spanking their six-month-old daughter Hosanna (pictured Friday)

BAKERSFIELD, CA - THE SCHOLARLY NOTE EXCLUSIVE

In a jaw-dropping scandal that's leaving fans of reality TV stunned, Bachelor #24 runner-up Madison Prewett Troutt and her husband Grant Troutt are sparking outrage with their shocking plans to spank their six-month-old daughter Hosanna Rose Troutt. The Christian power couple has left many in the online community questioning their parenting methods, citing biblical references that have been twisted to justify their actions.

On a recent episode of her popular podcast, Stay True, Madi, 29, gushed about spanking little Hosanna, saying "it will not kill them" and that it's a necessary form of discipline. Her husband Grant chimed in, grinning from ear to ear, as he exclaimed, "She's going to get a little bit!" The couple went on to explain how they plan to lovingly spank their daughter, claiming it's the best way to teach her obedience and that it's actually a sign of God's love.

The Christian couple cited the 'rod of correction' in the Bible referencing the symbolic shepherd who uses his tool to lovingly protect, guide, and correct his flock and as a weapon against predators (pictured last month)

The scandal began when vlogger Stephanie Tleiji shared the clip with her followers, which quickly went viral over the weekend. Twitter was ablaze with outrage as fans couldn't believe what they were hearing. "There's no hate like Christian love," one user sarcastically quipped, while another joked, "The rod isn't a literal rod, it means guidance." But for many, it was more than just a joke - it was a disturbing glimpse into the couple's warped parenting philosophy.

As news of their plans spread, fans began to dig up the couple's history and connections. It turns out that Madi's father spanked her as a child, which she now claims has given her a "unique" perspective on discipline. Her husband Grant is also no stranger to controversy, having worked with convicted child abuser Ruby Franke in the past.

But what's most alarming is the couple's influence and platform. With over 4 million followers on social media, they've become a powerful force in the Christian community, raking in thousands of dollars from brands like Cupshe and Amazon for their promotional posts. In fact, Madi's upcoming book, Dare to Be True: Defeat the Lies That Bind You and Live Out the Truth That Frees You, is set to be published by WaterBrook on September 23.

The 29-year-old pastor said on her Stay True Podcast: 'If Hosanna obeys us, we're not like,

As fans begin to question the couple's motives and sanity, it's clear that their actions are not only hurtful but also potentially illegal. "How is this not child abuse?" one user asked, while another warned, "They're making it easy for Child Protective Services." But will anyone take action? Only time will tell.

In a bizarre twist, the couple has scheduled speaking engagements at Trinity Church in Lubbock, TX and Extraordinary Women event in Lynchburg, VA in the coming months. Will they be able to justify their actions to their audience?

For now, fans are left stunned and shocked by the Troutts' twisted views on discipline. As one user aptly put it, "All I'm saying is they shouldn't be confused when their daughter goes no contact in 18 years."

The 29-year-old new mother added: 'It also specifically talks about discipline with the rod because some people could say,

UPDATE: Since going viral, the couple's social media following has taken a hit, with many fans unfollowing them in disgust. But for those who are still curious about this scandalous situation, we'll keep you updated on any new developments.

READ MORE ON THE SCHOLARLY NOTE

  • The Bachelor Franchise: A History of Failed Marriages and Broken Dreams
  • 10 Bachelorette Couples Who Still Managed to Make It Work
  • Inside the World of Christian Influencers: Where Profit Meets Pulpit

'It will not kill them,' Grant agreed. 'She going to get a little bit'

Share your thoughts on this scandal in the comments below! Do you think the Troutts are doing irreparable harm to their child? Should they be held accountable for their actions? Let's get the conversation started!

Sources:

  • The Scholarly Note Exclusive
  • Madi's Stay True Podcast (July 7)
  • Stephanie Tleiji's vlog
  • TikTok users @madisoneggimann, @thepaigechristiansen, @lyss868, @water.melon.knee, @jaidynsmith8800, and @chippayyy.

Madi will spank little Hosanna 'in a very loving way,' explaining: '

Prewett - whose father spanked her - continued: 'We are called to discipline [children] so that they may be more like Jesus so that they may be righteous and holy and so that they may understand that obedience is important'

And while the Troutts' controversial comments were technically made on July 7, Gossip vlogger Stephanie Tleiji (R) just made the clip go viral Saturday

'There's no hate like Christian love,' TikTok user @madisoneggimann commented

'The rod isn't a literal rod, it means guidance,' TikTok user @thepaigechristiansen corrected. 'What's terrifying is they don't actually study the Bible or the words'

TikTok user @water.melon.knee brought up Christian mommy vlogger-turned-convicted child abuser Ruby Franke, writing: 'Ruby Franke has entered the chat'

'Damn they're making it easy for [Child Protective Services],' TikTok user @jessforvine scoffed

The former foster parent recruiter's next speaking engagements are scheduled for September 19 at Trinity Church in Lubbock, TX followed by the Extraordinary Women event in Lynchburg, VA on October 10-11 (pictured Friday)

On September 23, WaterBrook will publish Madi's 240-page faith-based book Dare to Be True: Defeat the Lies That Bind You and Live Out the Truth That Frees You

It's only been five years since Delta Air Lines pilot Peter Weber (R) dumped his winning fiancée Hannah Ann Sluss for Prewett, who split from him just three days after the ABC dating competition's finale