Joshua Goldman
Joshua Goldman
min read · August 18, 2025 · Entertainment

Broadway Star Audra McDonald Stalked by Entitled Autograph Seeker

Broadway superstar Audra McDonald, 55, shared a chilling story about an autograph seeker who gave her bad vibes during an encounter Friday

BROADWAY STAR AUDRA McDONALD SHEDS LIGHT ON THE DARK SIDE OF AUTOGRAPH SEEKERS

The glamorous world of Broadway has a dirty little secret: some fans can get a little too close for comfort. Six-time Tony Award-winning superstar Audra McDonald recently shared a chilling tale about an autograph seeker who left her feeling shaken and vulnerable.

In an Instagram post on Saturday, the 55-year-old songstress revealed that she's been dodging the traditional stage door exit during her hit musical run of Gypsy at the Majestic Theatre. It seems that after hours of grueling performances, McDonald has had to find alternative ways to leave the theater without being mobbed by overzealous fans.

The star said the autograph seeker 'was uncomfortably close' to her at one point

But one particularly persistent fan took things too far. According to McDonald, this autograph seeker snuck around and managed to track her down outside the theater, following her all the way to her accommodation. The fan's justification? They'd traveled from afar to watch McDonald perform, so they felt entitled to an autograph as a "thank you."

McDonald, however, was not impressed. She recounted how she had to enlist security to deal with the situation, and even then, the fan seemed to think that their dedication warranted special treatment. When asked to leave, the autograph seeker reportedly retorted, "Well, hey, I've come all the way from [insert location]!"

This incident has sparked a much-needed conversation about boundaries in the entertainment industry. McDonald took to her platform to remind fans that performers have reasons for avoiding the stage door – it's not just because they're being rude or aloof.

The two-time Grammy winner said the autograph seeker made clear they felt entitled to her signature since they had visited NYC from a far-flung locale just to watch her take the stage

"When you see an actor leave the stage door, if they don't stop, leave them alone," she advised her 295,000-plus followers. "There's a reason they're not stopping, and it has nothing to do with you."

McDonald emphasized that performers are human beings, too, who need their space and time to recharge after a grueling performance. It's not about being rude or ungrateful; it's simply about maintaining their personal boundaries.

Fellow Tony Award-winner Kecia Lewis echoed McDonald's sentiments in a supportive comment on Instagram. "After 2.5 hours of stage time, and an hour or more of prep before performing, and giving 200% of your whole body, soul, and spirit to an audience, to then feel that you DESERVE more is the devil's work."

McDonald's friend and fellow Tony-winner, Kecia Lewis, added a supportive comment explaining what performers go through

This incident has sparked a heated debate about the entitlement of some fans. With the rise of social media, it's become all too easy for autograph seekers to track down their idols and demand signatures. And with the lucrative market for signed items on eBay and other platforms, some fans are willing to push boundaries to get what they want.

McDonald's experience is just the latest in a string of high-profile confrontations involving actors, musicians, and athletes. But it's also a timely reminder that performers deserve respect – not just for their talents, but for their humanity.

As McDonald put it, "It's them protecting their space and peace, whatever that may be." So next time you spot your favorite performer leaving the stage door, remember: if they don't stop to chat or sign an autograph, it's probably because they need some space – not because they're being rude.

McDonald is the first Black woman to play the vaunted role of Mama Rose on Broadway. Pictured in December

The Broadway staple said that she has not been using the stage door to exit the Majestic Theatre during Gypsy's run, citing 'a myriad of reasons' centered around protecting her health and conserving her energy