Joshua Goldman
Joshua Goldman
min read · August 1, 2025 · Entertainment

9 Years Later: Tobey Maguire and Jennifer Meyer's Ongoing Custody Battle

Tobey Maguire and his ex-wife Jennifer Meyer are still sorting their custody issues five years after they finalized their divorce; they are seen in 2016

Tobey Maguire's Custody Battle with Ex-Wife Jennifer Meyer Heats Up - Again!

It's been five long years since Tobey Maguire and his ex-wife Jennifer Meyer finalized their divorce, but it seems like the Spider-Man actor is still fighting for joint custody of their 16-year-old son Otis Tobias. And get this - Maguire is asking for a whopping reversal in his original agreement!

According to court documents obtained by TheScholarlyNote.com, Maguire, 50, wants joint legal and physical custody of Otis, citing concerns about his ex-wife's parenting skills. But wait, there's more! He's also requesting that child support be determined through private mediation - a clever move to keep the financial details out of the public eye.

The Spider-Man actor,50, and his former spouse, 48, share 16-year-old son Otis and 18-year-old Ruby; they are seen in 2016

The couple, who met in 2003 while Maguire was filming Seabiscuit, were married for nearly a decade before splitting in 2016. They share two children together: Ruby Sweetheart (18) and Otis Tobias (16). In their initial divorce statement, they emphasized that their top priority remained raising their kids together with love, respect, and friendship.

But it seems like Maguire has had a change of heart - or should we say, a change of custody agreement? The 50-year-old actor is now seeking to upend the original arrangement, sparking concerns about his motivations. Is he trying to exert more control over their son's life, or is this just a clever ploy to keep his ex-wife in line?

Meanwhile, Meyer, 48, has moved on with her life and is engaged to billionaire Geoffrey Ogunlesi, son of Nigerian billionaire lawyer Adebayo Ogunlesi. The pair have been inseparable since September, with Jennifer proudly showcasing their relationship on Instagram.

Maguire, right, with Lukas Haas at the 2025 Wimbledon Championships at the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club, London on July 11

But don't get too comfortable, folks! Maguire was spotted getting cozy with 22-year-old Danish model Mona Tougaard just a month after Meyer announced her engagement. And if that wasn't enough, sources close to the actor claim he's been linked to several young ladies during his European vacation last summer.

We can't help but wonder - is this a case of "he said, she said," or will Maguire finally get what he wants? Only time (and the courts) will tell!

Interestingly, Meyer has credited Gwyneth Paltrow for her amicable divorce from Chris Martin. Yes, you read that right! The jewelry designer appeared on The Broad Ideas podcast and shared how Paltrow's "conscious uncoupling" inspired her own approach to co-parenting with Maguire.

"I was like, 'Wow, that's not what I was taught growing up. I was taught that divorce was ugly … bad and would never be good,'" Meyer gushed about Paltrow's unique approach to divorce. "She introduced me to Dr. Habib Sadeghi, who helped us navigate our own separation."

But despite the amicable vibes between Maguire and his ex-wife, their custody battle continues to simmer in the background. Will we see a dramatic twist in this ongoing saga? Stay tuned!

In other news, Meyer was spotted shopping for a Christmas tree with her fiancé and son last December, while Maguire was snapped getting cozy with his young Danish model friend.

We can't help but feel that this drama-filled custody battle is far from over. As we wait with bated breath for the next development, one thing's for sure - Tobey Maguire's personal life will continue to be a hot topic in Hollywood!

Sources: TheScholarlyNote.com, People