Joshua Goldman
Joshua Goldman
min read · August 30, 2025 · Entertainment

20 Years Later: The Viral Comeback of the $1 Million Deception Show!

Controversial dating show Playing It Straight has resurfaced online a whole 20 years after it first aired, and it had a very famous presenter (2005 Channel 4 series)

The Jaw-Dropping Reality Show That Left Viewers Screaming for More!

Get ready for a blast from the past that's hotter than ever - the infamous dating show "Playing It Straight" is back in the spotlight, and trust us, it's about to get real!

This scandalous series first aired on Fox in 2005, but its UK version, which aired on Channel 4 from April to May of the same year, has left fans on X (formerly Twitter) utterly fascinated. The show was hosted by none other than American television personality Daphne Brogdon, with Jameela Jamil and comedian Alan Carr presenting the British spin-off.

The original series saw one woman have to pick a partner from 14 attractive bachelors, but the twist is that some of the men are gay

For those who may have missed it back in the day, "Playing It Straight" was a dating game where one woman would be paired with 14 handsome bachelors in a Mexican villa. Sounds innocent enough, right? Well, here's the twist: half of these guys were actually gay! The woman, blissfully unaware of this little secret, had to identify which ones were straight and win a whopping $1 million prize.

But if she picked a gay guy thinking he was straight, well, let's just say it was smooth sailing for him as he got to keep the cash all to himself. Ouch! The rules may have seemed straightforward (no pun intended), but the drama that unfolded on this show was anything but!

One X user, Corsaren, shared a thread of thoughts about the US series, which only ran for one season with eight episodes. They wrote: "Who do I have to pay to bring this show back on the air? Holy s**t!" We can't blame them - it's like they're begging for more!

Presenter Jameela Jamil hosted the 2012 series which aired on E4 for one season and eight episodes

As they continued their epic rant, Corsaren shared some juicy details about the contestants, including Gust, who was the first one to get booted from the show. Apparently, things got pretty wild after that! One of the X users claimed it was a time before TV shows banned booze on set (because, well, we all know what happens when you mix drinking and drama).

And speaking of drama, one contestant was "intentionally tricking another to take too many tequila shots" while another "decided to rip a** right next to the drunk guy." Yeah, it's safe to say things got pretty out of hand!

But the real kicker came when Jackie, the poor woman at the center of it all, found out about the twist. Her reaction was priceless - she was left sobbing, refusing to explain why (but let's be real, we know why!). As Corsaren quipped: "Jackie has just been told the twist. She is distraught but refuses to elaborate why. She's just crying lol."

The now-cancelled TV series - which first aired back in 2005 - originally broadcast on Fox in the US, but quickly turned into a UK version

As if that weren't enough, things only got juicier when another contestant got eliminated. And guess who was still reaping all the benefits? The gay guys, of course! Corsaren summed it up perfectly: "Oh s**t, another straighty bites the dust. The gays stay winning."

The X user's epic thread even caught the attention of other viewers, with some chiming in to share their own thoughts on the show. One person mentioned that they felt like everyone moved past the "dog named Gaydar" controversy too quickly (ouch!), while another pointed out that having a woman choose which guys stay based on who she's more comfortable with is just plain devious.

Meanwhile, someone else shared their memories of watching this show back in the day and compared it to another infamous reality series, "Joe Millionaire." We won't go into details about that one (suffice it to say it was a bit dodgy!), but let's just say these early 2000s reality shows were certainly... interesting.

Fans on X have rediscovered the gameshow, with one claiming that 'it got homophobic so quickly'

As fans continue to share their reactions online, one thing is clear: this show may have been short-lived, but its impact is still being felt. And who knows? Maybe we'll see a reboot in the future (although we can't promise that won't end up on our "nope, not interested" list).

So where does one find this gem of a show? Well, for those who are feeling nostalgic or just want to see what all the fuss is about, it originally aired on Channel 4 from April 8 to May 13, 2005 (for six episodes) and later on E4 from January 9 to February 27, 2012 (for eight episodes). Happy viewing!

Sources:

  • "Playing It Straight" episode summaries on TheScholarlyNote.com

Total words: 730

Meanwhile, other viewers joined in on sharing their thoughts, which included: 'I feel like everyone moved past the